Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Isabel's avatar

“They pestered him piteously until he gave them what he had.” This incident seems to me to strangely undermine your establishment of his character. He steals a much bigger item from those same kids like two pages later, and then the whole drama of the next few chapters is about him learning to let go of his desperation-driven rapaciousness in order to consider the needs of others. (Yes, I know there’s an element of self-interest in what he does with the silver, but even still.) You could certainly have Min La give them his leftovers to get rid of them—that would establish that he has the early seed of selflessness—but in my opinion it’s too early in his arc to portray him giving up the minimum that he needs for survival for the sake of people he doesn’t know. It really blunts the drama of the mini-arc in which he decides what to do with the silver because in view of this incident it seems like the type of choice he makes all the time, not a break from his previous habits of character.

On my initial reading I remembered feeling like this guy was really contradictory and difficult to figure out, and upon my second read I think this passage may be why.

I really love Min La’s character arc. He’s a fantastic character.

Jhaerlyn's avatar

I’d be lying if I said that I liked you cutting away from So Ga, … but Min La is interesting, mysterious. Is he a member of that disgraced noble family? Is he a prince that didn’t actually die? He’s not an urchin that was originally from the streets… is that why he has two names? I think he would have hidden and waited an hour to see if anyone followed before he reentered his temporary stone hut.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?